Comments: 12
janach [2011-11-05 15:45:29 +0000 UTC]
Regarding the criticism from the illo group: The boys' faces are certainly drawn very simply, the eyes in particular. But that's just a style. I'd call it "primitive" (in the artistic sense) rather than childish. Ron's eyes could use some work even if you keep the "primitive" style. They're different sizes and are looking in different directions.
As for the overall composition: I like the castle. Nicely abstract in the Scottish fog. The fuzzy gap between the two boys, however, seems to me a weakness. It looks like Hermione is supposed to be standing there. If you don't want to include her, I think the two figures should be somewhat larger and closer together, in order to lessen the gap. It's that foggy spot right in the center of of your composition that looks undefined to me, not Harry and Ron.
Final technical detail: "Philosopher's" needs an apostrophe.
Offered in the spirit of friendly helpfulness. You DID ask.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1